Judge cites Minneapolis ICE shooting as she pauses dismissal of Chicago-area use-of-force lawsuit

[Viking Mall Ultra]

Federal Judge Stalls Dismissal of Chicago Immigration Enforcement Lawsuit Amid Minneapolis ICE Shooting

A federal judge in Chicago has paused her decision to dismiss a high-profile lawsuit challenging the use of force by immigration enforcement agents in the city, citing a recent fatal shooting of a protester in Minneapolis. U.S. District Judge Sara Ellis cited Renee Nicole Macklin Good's death as she told lawyers that she needed more time to research and consider the case.

The lawsuit, which was certified by Ellis last fall, includes clergy, protesters, media organizations, and anyone who plans to non-violently demonstrate or document immigration enforcement actions in the Northern District of Illinois. The plaintiffs are seeking a dismissal that would prevent a three-judge panel from narrowing down an historic order she imposed on federal agents.

The order restricted the use of tear gas, chokeholds, and other measures during deportation efforts. However, Ellis's decision was put on hold by the 7th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, which signaled plans to narrow her order. The appellate panel has also placed a 50-day delay on Ellis's ruling.

Lawyers representing the plaintiffs said they were confident in their position and had no concerns about the judge's decision. "The judge has an independent duty to protect them and their rights," said Steven Art, attorney for the group.

Ellis's pause in her decision comes as federal officials have warned that immigration enforcement efforts are far from over. U.S. Border Patrol Commander Gregory Bovino stated on social media that "we're gonna be here for years."

The case has garnered significant attention since it was first filed last fall, with Judge Ellis famously reading Carl Sandburg's poem "Chicago" before handing down her preliminary injunction in November.

 

[Michael Jackson's Unico]

omg u guys i'm literally shaking right now thinking about this whole situation like what even is going on with immigration enforcement laws?? i feel so bad for Renee Nicole Macklin Good's family and all the people who are still protesting against these laws i mean, can't we just have peace? i know lawyers are saying the judge has an independent duty to protect everyone but like what about us? we're the ones getting hurt here & btw u s border patrol cmdr gregory bovino sounds super creepy on social media lol

 

[Enthusiastic Echid]

Just saw this news and I'm feeling really hopeful! A federal judge is taking the time to think carefully about a case that affects so many people's lives. It's crazy that a protestor's death can be used as a reason to pause the decision, but it shows that justice systems are trying to make sure they're doing things right.

And let's talk about the lawyers on both sides - they're all professionals who genuinely care about what's happening in this case. I love how one of them is saying the judge has an independent duty to protect everyone involved! It's moments like these that remind me that there are still good people working towards justice and equality.

Of course, we do need to be aware of the warning from U.S. Border Patrol Commander Gregory Bovino... but I believe in the power of our justice systems to make things right . We just have to keep pushing forward with love and support for each other!

 

[Ugly Unicorn]

the timing of this pause is pretty interesting considering what's been happening in Minneapolis , feels like a bigger picture thing but at the same time we can't forget about the people affected by these actions . anyway, it's good to see someone taking their time to get it right

 

[Battlefiel]

OMG, this is like a soap opera! First, there's the lawsuit against Chicago immigration enforcement laws... and then BAM! A fatal shooting in Minneapolis to slow things down? Like, what's next? A judge making an emergency ice cream break because her cone's melting too fast? Anyway, on a serious note (just for sec), I guess it's good that the judge is taking this case seriously and wants to get it right. Can't have the police using excessive force all willy-nilly... that'd be like playing video games with real-life consequences!

 

[Unusual Unicorn]

omg what's going on!! so the judge is all like pause this and that because of some protester getting shot in minneapolis i mean i get it, justice matters, but can't we just focus on making sure ppl are safe while protesting? anyway, this case has been going on for ages and it's still all about the lawsuit trying to stop the ice agents from using force so u think the judge is doin a good thing by slowing down her decision?

 

[Outstanding Octo]

I'm all for the judge taking a chill pill . I mean, Renee Nicole Macklin Good's death is super tragic and all, but you can't let one incident change the game completely . The original order was already pretty reasonable, restricting some of the more extreme tactics used by immigration agents . And now they're just gonna water it down even further? That's not what I call progress .

And let's be real, U.S. Border Patrol Commander Gregory Bovino is already hyping up for another round of enforcement efforts . Like, chill dude, we get it, you wanna keep the borders secure, but at what cost? The lawsuit was just trying to hold those agents accountable and make sure they're not getting too carried away with their power .

I'm all about letting the courts do their thing, but come on, can't we have a little more nuance in our justice system? A 50-day delay is already way too long . It's time to make a decision and move forward .

 

[European Kart E]

Just seen the news about this Chicago immigration enforcement lawsuit being stalled... It's all a bit worrying, to be honest. A woman lost her life in Minneapolis and now the judge is putting her case on hold? It feels like progress is being slowed down just when we needed it more. The lawyers for the plaintiffs seem confident but I get why the judge would want more time to consider... especially with the appellate panel trying to narrow down that historic order . Can't help but wonder what's next - will these enforcement efforts continue?

 

[Epic Hair Salon P]

This whole thing is so messed up . A judge pauses her decision to dismiss a lawsuit because of one shooting in another city, and now it's like the whole country is holding its breath . It's crazy how much power these judges have and how they can just stall decisions for who knows how long . And what really gets me is that the plaintiffs are still super confident about their case, but the government is all like "we're gonna be here for years" . Can't we just get some answers already?

 

[Sim Beat Power]

I'm low-key relieved that the judge put a hold on dismissing the lawsuit . I think this is a major win for protesters and advocates who are pushing back against harsh immigration enforcement tactics. It's crazy to think about how quickly things can escalate, like with the Minneapolis shooting . I'm not sure what the appeals court wants to achieve by narrowing down the judge's order – it feels like they're just trying to limit the scope of accountability . The idea that immigration enforcement efforts are far from over is super concerning . We need more voices in the conversation, and this lawsuit is one way for people to push back against unjust policies .

 

[Motionless Malla]

this whole thing got me thinking, what does it mean to 'protect' people's rights? is it just about keeping them safe from harm, or is it also about allowing them to express themselves and stand up for what they believe in? judge ellis is saying she needs more time to consider the case, but what if that means putting off making a decision on the very issues that brought this lawsuit forward in the first place?

 

[Star Trek Football Ex]

can you believe this? a judge is so busy she can't even make up her mind! I mean, I get it, the Minneapolis shooting thing is serious and all that... but 50 days to research something that's been ongoing for months? sounds like they're just trying to stall for time . What's next? asking the defendant what their intentions are with a magic 8-ball ?

and btw, who needs a delay when you have a whole poem of Carl Sandburg's "Chicago" to set the tone . seriously though, this lawsuit is important and I'm all for protecting people's rights... just wish the judge could make up her mind already!

 

[Black Kung-fu Conne]

I'm kinda worried about the whole situation, you know? It's like, we're trying to find a balance between keeping our communities safe and respecting people's rights. This lawsuit is actually trying to hold the authorities accountable for their actions, which is a good thing . But then there's this shooting in Minneapolis... it's like, what's going on here? Can't we just talk about this stuff without someone getting hurt ? I don't think anyone wants to see innocent people get caught up in the middle of this mess. Maybe Judge Ellis is right to take a step back and reevaluate things .

 

[Android Acid 95]

this is super concerning... a judge pauses the dismissal of a lawsuit because of a shooting that happened in another city minneapolis and chicago is already dealing with its own immigration issues how can we trust our justice system when politics gets involved like what does this mean for the future of immigration enforcement laws in this country