Cloud seeding experiment launched in Delhi as air quality spirals out of control.
The Indian government has taken a step towards cleaning up Delhi's notorious air pollution by launching a cloud-seeding experiment. This ambitious plan aims to induce artificial rain and reduce the city's notoriously poor air quality, which has been ranked as the worst in the world for over a decade.
The experiment involves using aircraft or drones to disperse silver iodide particles into clouds, which are believed to stimulate precipitation. The plan was first proposed by the ruling Bharatiya Janata party earlier this year but was put on hold due to unpredictable weather patterns. However, with air quality hitting hazardous levels after Diwali festivities, the government has finally rolled out the scheme.
The trial flight took place recently, and officials claim that Delhi will experience its first artificial rain on October 29th if conditions remain favorable. However, experts have raised concerns about the effectiveness of cloud seeding as a solution to air pollution. According to Shahzad Gani and Krishna AchutaRao, two professors at Delhi's Centre for Atmospheric Sciences, the plan is a "gimmick" that ignores the root causes of pollutants.
The scientists argue that cloud seeding has limited success in producing more frequent and heavier rain, and it does not address the underlying issues driving pollution. Moreover, there is little research on the long-term effects of repeated use of chemicals like silver iodide or sodium chloride on agriculture and human health.
Critics also point out that Delhi's air quality problems are complex and multifaceted, requiring more comprehensive solutions than a single experiment can provide. The city's air pollution levels have been rising steadily over the past few years, with PM2.5 and PM 10 levels often exceeding those seen in Beijing during its infamous "airpocalypse" in 2013.
While the cloud seeding experiment may offer some short-term relief, it is unlikely to be a panacea for Delhi's air pollution woes. As experts warn, snake-oil solutions like this gimmick are unlikely to clear the air and require more fundamental changes to tackle the root causes of pollutants.
The Indian government has taken a step towards cleaning up Delhi's notorious air pollution by launching a cloud-seeding experiment. This ambitious plan aims to induce artificial rain and reduce the city's notoriously poor air quality, which has been ranked as the worst in the world for over a decade.
The experiment involves using aircraft or drones to disperse silver iodide particles into clouds, which are believed to stimulate precipitation. The plan was first proposed by the ruling Bharatiya Janata party earlier this year but was put on hold due to unpredictable weather patterns. However, with air quality hitting hazardous levels after Diwali festivities, the government has finally rolled out the scheme.
The trial flight took place recently, and officials claim that Delhi will experience its first artificial rain on October 29th if conditions remain favorable. However, experts have raised concerns about the effectiveness of cloud seeding as a solution to air pollution. According to Shahzad Gani and Krishna AchutaRao, two professors at Delhi's Centre for Atmospheric Sciences, the plan is a "gimmick" that ignores the root causes of pollutants.
The scientists argue that cloud seeding has limited success in producing more frequent and heavier rain, and it does not address the underlying issues driving pollution. Moreover, there is little research on the long-term effects of repeated use of chemicals like silver iodide or sodium chloride on agriculture and human health.
Critics also point out that Delhi's air quality problems are complex and multifaceted, requiring more comprehensive solutions than a single experiment can provide. The city's air pollution levels have been rising steadily over the past few years, with PM2.5 and PM 10 levels often exceeding those seen in Beijing during its infamous "airpocalypse" in 2013.
While the cloud seeding experiment may offer some short-term relief, it is unlikely to be a panacea for Delhi's air pollution woes. As experts warn, snake-oil solutions like this gimmick are unlikely to clear the air and require more fundamental changes to tackle the root causes of pollutants.
. They should be focusing on more effective ways to reduce pollution, like increasing public transport and bike lanes or promoting cleaner industries. Silver iodide particles are basically just chemicals with unknown long-term effects... what's the hurry?
omg u guys i'm so down for cloud seeding!!! 
seriously though, i know some experts are skeptical but like what's the harm right? 
we've gotta try anything at this point! 
and btw, 29th october can't come soon enough 
i just wanna see some rain in my city already! 
️
Please, experts have already said it's a gimmick that ignores the real issues. Like, what about all the industrial stuff and vehicle emissions that are actually causing the pollution? And don't even get me started on the whole silver iodide thing... has anyone thought about the long-term effects of using chemicals like that in our atmosphere?! 
. Experts are calling out this gimmick for what it is - a fancy Band-Aid solution that ignores the root causes of pollution. Silver iodide or sodium chloride ain't gonna save Delhi's air quality on its own 
. And let's not forget the long-term effects of using all these chemicals... yikes, sounds like a recipe for disaster 
. I guess we'll just have to wait and see if this "artificial rain" makes it to the city before October 29th... probably more likely to clear up the scientists' notes than the air 
.
But for real though, have you seen the air quality in Delhi lately? It's crazy 
. This cloud seeding thing is like trying to fix a leaky bucket with duct tape 
... it might hold for a sec, but it's not gonna last.
india needs to take a hard look at its industrial policies and transport emissions or else it's just going to keep breathing in toxic air. and what about all those trucks spewing PM2.5 into the atmosphere? we need to crack down on pollution from vehicles ASAP!
. What's a little artifical rain when you're already drowning in smog? It's not like it'll make a huge difference, but hey, it's a nice distraction from the real issues. I mean, who needs clean air when you can have "artificial" rain to take pics with? 
It's all about the optics, right? The gov's trying to look good for the cameras, and who knows, maybe it'll just give 'em a chance to figure out what's really going on. Plus, what's a bit of particulate matter when you've got a nice, clean (ish) bill of goods to show for it? Let's just hope they don't get too carried away with the gimmickry 
what do u think about cloud seeding in delhi? its good idea or total waste of resources? 
anyway, sounds to me like the scientists are being super realistic - all that silver iodide and sodium chloride stuff is a mystery to them. have u heard of any other cloud seeding experiments going on around the world? 
could it be a new way to make money or what? 
it's crazy how much ppl are relying on some gimmicky cloud seeding experiment 2 try & clean up the air 
there r so many other factors at play here, like pollution from construction, transportation, etc. 
and what about the economic side? this experiment is gonna cost who knows how much $$$ 
& ppl are still breathing in toxic air 
we need real solutions 2 tackle the root causes of pollution, not just some half-baked tech idea 
. And what about all the other factors that make Delhi's air so bad? Like, its not just one thing thats causin pollution. Its complex 
. Can't we just start reducin our emissions and stuff instead of tryin out wacky experiments? 
.