How the left can win back the internet – and rise again | Robert Topinka

This article discusses how the internet has changed the way politics is expressed and debated, particularly on social media platforms. The author argues that the right-wing movement has adapted to the online environment more effectively than the left, using algorithms to spread emotionally charged and divisive content. In contrast, liberals and progressives have focused on traditional media outlets and follower-focused platforms, which limits their ability to engage with and critique conservative ideas.

The article highlights several key points:

1. The shift from a "town square" model of social media to one that prioritizes engagement and emotional resonance.
2. The rise of reactionaries and right-wing influencers on social media, who use platforms like Twitter and TikTok to spread divisive content and build online communities.
3. The left's tendency to focus on competition rather than cooperation with other left-wing groups, leading to infighting and a lack of cohesive messaging.
4. The importance of building alternative online ecosystems and amplifying progressive voices, rather than simply competing for attention in the current media landscape.

The article concludes by suggesting that there are signs of life on the online left, including the emergence of new forms of comedy and commentary that critique conservative ideologies. However, more needs to be done to build a cohesive and effective online presence for progressives, and to engage with and critique conservative ideas in a meaningful way.

Some key quotes from the article include:

* "The right has established its own parallel media universe. It eschews most real news and instead tells convincing tales about how the shadowy functionaries of the Cathedral, or the matrix, or cultural Marxism lie to you in the media and try to control your every action."
* "Instead of building an alternative new media ecosystem and amplifying each other's work, the left focuses more on competition than the right. As the right convenes the intellectual dark web and manosphere, leftwing digital media is a scattered landscape of Substacks and X-to-Bluesky hot-take artists."
* "The centre right is often happy to engage with ideas from the right, but liberals and the left actively balk at exchanging ideas."

Overall, the article offers a critical analysis of the current state of online politics and argues that progressives need to adapt their strategies in order to effectively compete with the right on social media.
 
omg i totally agree w/ this article!!! 🤯 the way conservatives are using algorithms 2 spread divisive content is soooo clever, but we can't let them win! 😡 we need 2 build our own online communities & amplify progressive voices ASAP! 💪 it's like, we can't just compete with them 4 attention, we gotta create our own movement! 🌈 and omg yeah, the left's infighting is SO not cool... 👯‍♀️ we need 2 work together & support each other instead of tearing each other down! 💕
 
🤔 This whole thing is pretty interesting, you know? It's like, people are saying that the internet has changed how we do politics, especially when it comes to social media. I think this shift from a "town square" model to one where engagement and emotional resonance matter more is kinda crazy. We're not just talking about our tweets and Facebook posts anymore, but like, a whole online ecosystem.

And yeah, the right-wing movement seems to be using algorithms pretty smartly to spread stuff that gets people all fired up. Meanwhile, the left is still trying to figure out how to use these platforms effectively. It's kinda frustrating when you're over here trying to have a rational conversation and it feels like nobody's listening.

On the other hand, I do think there are some promising signs on the left side of things... like that new wave of comedians and commentators who are tackling conservative ideologies in a really clever way. But we need to work on building these alternative online spaces where people can actually have meaningful conversations without all the noise and distractions.

It's not an easy problem, but I think it's cool when we start seeing people having these kinds of conversations. Maybe we can even learn from each other...
 
man... i feel like we're stuck in this echo chamber where people are more interested in getting likes than having real conversations 🤯. it's crazy how algorithms can spread hate speech so fast, and yet we still haven't figured out how to counter that with meaningful content 📊. i think the left needs to focus on building a community that uplifts each other rather than competing against conservatives all the time 💪. let's try to create online spaces where people feel safe sharing their thoughts and ideas without fear of judgment 😌. and btw, those reactionaries on tiktok are lowkey terrifying 🎉. we need to take social media back from them and make it a platform for progressive voices 👍.
 
So I was watching this vlog on YouTube about gaming and it made me think... what's the deal with online communities? Like, how do they form and stay together? 🤔 I mean, my friend has like 10k followers on TikTok but she doesn't really talk to them that much. She just posts these funny videos and then it's all done. It's like, are people even engaging with each other or is it just a bunch of noise? 😂

And this article about politics online is making me think... how can we build a community without being toxic? Like, I see some people on Twitter getting so worked up over everything and it's just not cool. Can't we all just talk to each other and agree to disagree? 🤷‍♀️
 
I mean, have you seen these stats on Twitter? 🤯 The right-wing movement has got like 4x more followers than liberals! 📊 And it's not just about numbers, but also engagement - right-wing influencers are raking in millions from ads and sponsorships! 💸 Meanwhile, the left is still stuck in traditional media, trying to compete with a foe that's optimized for online warfare. It's like we're playing catch-up. 🤦‍♀️ Did you know 70% of conservatives on Twitter identify as "influencers" despite having no formal credentials? 🚫 That's some serious grassroots power! 💪 The left needs to get their act together and build a parallel ecosystem - it's time to stop fighting among ourselves and start building a coalition that can take down the right-wing machine! 🔒
 
lol what's up with these algorithms tho? they're like designed to make us all anxious and divided 🤯♂️

anyway, it's wild how the right is just owning the online space now 🚀♂️. those reactionaries are like pros at spreading hate and fear 😩

and yeah, the left needs to step up its game too 🏋️‍♀️. we can't keep relying on traditional media outlets when the internet is where it's at 🔥

I'm loving this new wave of comedy and commentary that's popping up online though 😂🤣. it's like, finally some people are speaking truth to power without being all preachy or whatever 🙏

but for real, building alternative online ecosystems is key 💻. we need to create our own spaces where we can have real conversations and not just get stuck in this echo chamber stuff 🔗

anyway, gotta say, I'm both excited and terrified about the future of online politics 🤯♂️🔥
 
I'm thinking, man... 🤔 The way we're talking about this stuff is wild 📱. I mean, think about it - we're living in a time where algorithms are deciding what we see and hear online 😬. It's crazy how easily you can get sucked into this vortex of outrage and division. Like, have you noticed how some social media platforms just seem to amplify the most inflammatory stuff? 🤯 It's like they're actively trying to make us all more angry and less civil 💔.

And yeah, I think it's true that the right has been pretty effective at using these platforms to spread their message. But the left can't just sit back and wait for them to come to us, you know? 🤷‍♀️ We need to be proactive about building our own online communities and spreading our own ideas. It's not always easy, but I think we've got some good people out there trying to do just that 💪.

I'm curious - what do you guys think is the most important thing for progressives to focus on in terms of building an effective online presence? 🤔 Should we be more about competing with the right, or should we be focusing on building our own alternative ecosystem? 🌐 Let me know your thoughts! 💬
 
Back
Top